My Compo 25: Remake a Game submission.
This level represents the first level of the third episode (Keen must Die!) of the Commander Keen: Invasion of the Voricons trilogy.
This map was quite a challenge for me because making a first person shooter level from a platform run and jump level is pretty tough, because i had to convert the 2D platform leveldesign into 3D leveldesign. Also, i made a working score system! Score points by touching the various items lying around the map. I think this is quite unique for a FPS game.
Enjoy!
I would definitely take this further if i could get a coder, modeller and texture artist...
The textures and architecture are very simple. I can see from the screenshots this is how the original game was, but i think it would be ok if you took liberties with the original design, to make it more interesting to the player... it's just too blocky and boring.
I would make the "coin" thingies 3-dimensional objects... they just look too weird as 2D in a 3D world. Same with the invisible clips, i understand why you do it to simulate the 2D environment, but i don't think it works well.
I was going to make a 2d metroid mod similar to what you're doing here, but i ran into many of the issues you're running into here.
The sounds for picking up the coins are cool. I would add some game music in the background too(was there background music in the original?).
The scoring counter and the minimap at the beginning are neat things, and nicely done.
This might actually work better as Flat-Life Game for Chickenfist's mod! = )