Andy, is it alright to post links to the maps in situ on this server?
trapt:
OriginalityPretty original ? for the engine, at least.
ArchitectureSome excellent VMing for terrain (again ;)).
TexturingA little plain, and, for the volcano 'lava', dowright strange.
LightingWell, it's lit.
Entity workI didn't notice any particularly amazing entity trickery.
ImpressionStarts excellently, but gets a little strange toward the end.
OverallDoesn't appear to be completable. Very pretty, though.
Kasperg:
OriginalityWow. Sickeningly, stunningly surreal. Love it.
ArchitectureA little on the square side in parts, with some slightly odd scaling.
TexturingLack of NULL textures on some glass sides looked a little strange. Double door textures on single doors.
LightingA little unsubtle. Could have been more atmospheric in parts.
Entity workThe boat below was impressive, but the parallax showed its true distance. So was the blurring of Breen, and the race ? plus, of course, the slightly strangely-made ShoutBOX with the moving brushes :).
ImpressionThe progress bar, wow. Why did nobody think of that before? Great stuff.
OverallReally nice. The ShoutBOX actually made me laugh out loud. The final path was really surreal, too. By far my favourite.
rowleybob:
OriginalityYay! Transformers! Very nice.
ArchitectureLargely on the blocky side, but I must say, the window part things look axcellent, as do the 'bots.
TexturingA little lazy. Could have used some custom textures.
LightingNone?
Entity workWell-arranged. You could jump on bits that I don't think you were meant to be able to, though.
ImpressionNice splash things. Bit like Kasperg's, actually.
OverallPretty nice, but again, unconnected and short.