https://archive.is/PaB5b A part of me wants to feel bad for this guy, since I think out off all the new paid-mod stuff going on, he is definitely getting the most shit. And Valve is pretty much treating him like shit. I want to call him the fall guy for all of this, seems like he was sweet talked into something then when he really needed Valve's support they just kind of ignored him. Whole situation sucks.
As for the guy who used a dependency that
was separate, I still think it's a shitty thing to do, but if no one downloads the dependency he technically isn't profiting off of another person's work right?
Why can't we just have a donation button or thing that's supported by Valve/Steam? Why do they and Bethesda HAVE to make money off of it, haven't they already made enough by people BUYING the game? And also, why is Valve possibly deleting links to donation pages on certain mods?
https://i.imgur.com/wW5j5yu.png (this mod was actually taken off the workshop, so I'm not sure what's going on there).
I feel like the entire field of modding just got a lot more confusing and shitty. Just think about what this would do to other games. Garry's Mod, Space Engineers, Portal 2, L4D2. All of these games really rely on the modders to keep them alive for years and years after they normally would run otherwise(which is probably why Skyrim was chosen to beta this, it's a prime example of that). If all of these had paid-mods, would anyone actually buy them? I know I personally wouldn't, it's not that I don't think they should get supported for their work, they should, just not in this way.
There are more things I want to say but I'm about to crash.
EDIT: Also, agree with your first 3 points, 1 made me laugh, imagine a 'free trial' for a mod. I mean hell, someone already had an early access mod that would go up in price when it came out of development.