The Map Vault Review-a-thon
Created 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:17:42 UTC by
Daubster
Created 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:17:42 UTC by
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 13:17:41 UTC
Post #153435
Wait.. You don't have to review every map.. By 'every' i meant that you can review any map, no matter the mod or vault..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 13:19:54 UTC
Post #153436
Alright now your making some sense.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 13:51:12 UTC
Post #153451
Ow daubster, i'm in by the way.
I'll probaly won't win but I got nothing to lose..
I'll probaly won't win but I got nothing to lose..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 13:57:08 UTC
Post #153458
ive posted a few revies, dial up is kinda prohibiting me from doing them en masse.
are you going to be weighting the people who have dial up due to their handicap? as to give them a better chance?
are you going to be weighting the people who have dial up due to their handicap? as to give them a better chance?
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 14:08:27 UTC
Post #153462
this sucks >_< i wish i hadn't released those 2 maps.. everyone is pimping points out of reviewing them when i cant >_<
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 14:11:44 UTC
Post #153464
@M_Gargly: You wish.. 
@FresheD: Ya, I noticed your review..
@FresheD: Ya, I noticed your review..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 14:12:19 UTC
Post #153465
Meh, don't worry, I think you or elon will win anyway..
I reviewed some maps with a simple "Very fun" in the past etc..
I might aswell get a detailed review on those maps aswell..
(I reviewed symantry's maps and crystalmans, daubster hint hint)
I reviewed some maps with a simple "Very fun" in the past etc..
I might aswell get a detailed review on those maps aswell..
(I reviewed symantry's maps and crystalmans, daubster hint hint)
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 14:18:24 UTC
Post #153471
i might try if i have some time 
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 14:26:47 UTC
Post #153475
oh come on, Daubster! Can you blame me?!
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 19:24:45 UTC
Post #153594
I don?t think i?ll win, i don?t have enough time so im just gonna review 5 or 6 maps i think... But atleast i can?t lose anything
what a bummer if you got suspended for like a week if you lose a competition
what a bummer if you got suspended for like a week if you lose a competition
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-22 13:50:10 UTC
Post #153957
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooes!
Damn it, I was writing a big-ass review on elon yariv's map that actually took me a while because it was so long and I finally post it and I get 'Whoopseh!' and I need to re-login!
Now I need to write it al over again..
EDIT : Rewrited, but it's shorter now, it's still pretty long.
Damn it, I was writing a big-ass review on elon yariv's map that actually took me a while because it was so long and I finally post it and I get 'Whoopseh!' and I need to re-login!
Now I need to write it al over again..
EDIT : Rewrited, but it's shorter now, it's still pretty long.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-22 15:05:18 UTC
Post #153973
You should copy your post before you try to post it if you have taken a little while.
I always do, incase of that.
I always do, incase of that.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-22 15:35:03 UTC
Post #153981
Yea..
I do the same, when writing reviews..
I do the same, when writing reviews..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 05:20:47 UTC
Post #154251
Only 1 day left, so get reviewin'.
I'll post the results tomorrow.
I'll post the results tomorrow.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 05:21:30 UTC
Post #154253
I'll review more maps. I checked them all already.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 06:23:50 UTC
Post #154261
I'm not very good at this 
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 06:24:31 UTC
Post #154262
Yes you are..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 06:26:54 UTC
Post #154263
Only sees 3 Reveiws done by me* Are you sure?
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 06:57:24 UTC
Post #154271
clears throat
Uhm... distracts Ansith and runs away
Uhm... distracts Ansith and runs away
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 11:09:30 UTC
Post #154304
hint hint Ansith, maybe you should write some more detailed reviews then just pro's and cons? hint hint 
Meh, I hope I win, reviewed a bunch of maps lately, boringness eh'..
Meh, I hope I win, reviewed a bunch of maps lately, boringness eh'..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-24 22:20:09 UTC
Post #154387
Im pretty sure im not going to win this... Think i?ve reviewed 3 or 4 maps... And im not sure if they are any good... But atleast i don?t think im about to win and then get disapointed...
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 06:11:59 UTC
Post #154394
Well the compo is over.
I'll check the MV one more time, when I'll get home, calculate the scores and post em'..
Thanks for participating, everyone!
I'll check the MV one more time, when I'll get home, calculate the scores and post em'..
Thanks for participating, everyone!
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 10:00:22 UTC
Post #154419
Excellent stuff, all, Anthony included :). Nice idea.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 14:44:04 UTC
Post #154457
- The results -
1st place - Rowleybob (average of 4.1 and a total of 4.9)
2nd place - Elon Yariv (average of 4.6 and a total of 4.7)
And 3rd place - Tosse (average of 4.1 and a total of 4.6)
Congratulations, Rowleybob - the winner of the Map vault review-a-thon.
For those, who want to see the whole scores - here is the excel document with all of the ratings, map names, etc.
Now as you have noticed, the final score isn't only the average of all the ratings. The final score was the the average of the sum of all the ratings plus the number of reviews. E.g if a member made 3 reviews that were evaluated in 5*,4*,5* - the final score would be calculated like that:
(5 + 4 + 5 + 3) / 4
I would also like to thank the other competitors:
FresheD, The Hunter, M_Gargantua, Ansith, Spooky, SpaG and Shadowhunter
Thanks for participating. It was really nice to see the MV active again..
1st place - Rowleybob (average of 4.1 and a total of 4.9)
2nd place - Elon Yariv (average of 4.6 and a total of 4.7)
And 3rd place - Tosse (average of 4.1 and a total of 4.6)
Congratulations, Rowleybob - the winner of the Map vault review-a-thon.
For those, who want to see the whole scores - here is the excel document with all of the ratings, map names, etc.
Now as you have noticed, the final score isn't only the average of all the ratings. The final score was the the average of the sum of all the ratings plus the number of reviews. E.g if a member made 3 reviews that were evaluated in 5*,4*,5* - the final score would be calculated like that:
(5 + 4 + 5 + 3) / 4
I would also like to thank the other competitors:
FresheD, The Hunter, M_Gargantua, Ansith, Spooky, SpaG and Shadowhunter
Thanks for participating. It was really nice to see the MV active again..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 14:45:56 UTC
Post #154459
NOES!!!!
Freshed cries in a corner
Freshed cries in a corner
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 14:46:53 UTC
Post #154460
You were 4th, FresheD..
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 14:47:44 UTC
Post #154461
Yeah, because I reviewed almost every map in the vault from 1 nov!
Freshed Waves His Award Goodbye, still crying
Freshed Waves His Award Goodbye, still crying
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 14:57:10 UTC
Post #154465
Damn.. I posted the scores wrong.. 
Elon had a total of 4.8 and Tosse had a total of 4.7
Elon had a total of 4.8 and Tosse had a total of 4.7
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 15:20:40 UTC
Post #154467
I would also like to thank the other competitors:Too bad i didn't have time to participate :(. Though i wanted to. Oh well
FresheD, The Hunter, M_Gargantua, Ansith, Spooky, SpaG and Shadowhunter
Oh and congratulations Rowley!
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 15:48:30 UTC
Post #154472
Elon had a total of 4.8 and Tosse had a total of 4.7Does it really matter?
Am I going to get a reward too?
[usless whine]To bad I don't have CS... there are more CS maps in the vault lately, and I couldn't comment on them. Almost commented on every Hl1 map though. I'll stop whining now! [/usless whine]
Congratulations rowleybob anyway!
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 16:33:52 UTC
Post #154478
@ FresheD: If you want a Map Vault award, get mapping! Sounds pretty easy to me.
Congrats to Rowley.
Congrats to Rowley.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 19:05:01 UTC
Post #154492
Though all of you made good efforts, I can't hand them out to everyone, or there'd be no incentive to remain involved. We will have similar things again, don't worry. Keep reviewing and you could just win one silently: the only reason this was necessary is because few people were. Use your initiative (like Dauby :)) and you could end up with one soon too.
rowleybob, the clear winner, and FresheD, who participated massively, excusing his slightly poorer average (so much more work: well done, mate; personal commendation from Daubster) will be given their awards tommorow.
Don't despair if you didn't get anything this time 'round, folks. Keep being helpful and you'll get your silverware.
rowleybob, the clear winner, and FresheD, who participated massively, excusing his slightly poorer average (so much more work: well done, mate; personal commendation from Daubster) will be given their awards tommorow.
Don't despair if you didn't get anything this time 'round, folks. Keep being helpful and you'll get your silverware.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 20:39:22 UTC
Post #154515
Cool 3rd place ^^ That?s unexpected! 
I didn?t think i was going to be even top 5 ^^
I didn?t think i was going to be even top 5 ^^
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 22:22:33 UTC
Post #154522
hmm.. if i hadn't given up after releasing those 2 maps of mine, i probably would have had a chance. ach well....
You haven't heard the last of me.
puts on reviewing gloves
You haven't heard the last of me.
puts on reviewing gloves
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-25 23:46:25 UTC
Post #154533
Thank you! What a beautiful christmas present this is!
Kudos to Elon Yariv--was right on my tail, it appears--, Tosse, and to everyone else who made this a worthwhile contest!
<rowleybob screams for joy, and runs around doing the "award dance">
Kudos to Elon Yariv--was right on my tail, it appears--, Tosse, and to everyone else who made this a worthwhile contest!
<rowleybob screams for joy, and runs around doing the "award dance">
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-26 02:10:13 UTC
Post #154542
Good work rowley :D.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-26 05:23:46 UTC
Post #154548
I finally saw the light! 
I don't care that I'm not in the first place, it was good anyway for it gave me a habit of reviewing maps.
I don't care that I'm not in the first place, it was good anyway for it gave me a habit of reviewing maps.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-26 06:52:58 UTC
Post #154552
Excellent stuff, and good sportsmanship, fellas :). Delighted with how this has worked out.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-26 09:10:21 UTC
Post #154581
I had mostly 4's and 5's thought.
A few 3's because I was lazy to write long detailed reviews sometimes..
useless whine I got a 1? I didn't knew I reviewed that map
You missed my review on kaspergs map! useless whine
A well, I got a award now! Freshed Dances
Congratulations to rowleybob aswell and a big thanks @ daubster.
A few 3's because I was lazy to write long detailed reviews sometimes..
useless whine I got a 1? I didn't knew I reviewed that map
You missed my review on kaspergs map! useless whine
A well, I got a award now! Freshed Dances
Congratulations to rowleybob aswell and a big thanks @ daubster.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-26 09:24:57 UTC
Post #154584
Good work FresheD, and everyone else.
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-26 09:40:14 UTC
Post #154587
[reply to Elon's useless whine] You can easily run CS maps on HL and comment on everything except the gameplay :P[/reply to Elon's useless whine]
[reply to FresheD's useless whine]That review sucked... And did I miss that one? Sorry.. :confused:[/reply to FresheD's useless whine]
@Tosse: Your reviews were really constructive and.. Well really great.. Although you needed more to win.. :
@Hunter:
[reply to FresheD's useless whine]That review sucked... And did I miss that one? Sorry.. :confused:[/reply to FresheD's useless whine]
@Tosse: Your reviews were really constructive and.. Well really great.. Although you needed more to win.. :
@Hunter:
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-26 11:59:28 UTC
Post #154604
Congrats rowley! You did win this so you must have done a great job!
@ Daubster: Thank you! Well my girlfriend was here so i didn?t have more time but im very happy with my 3rd place
@ Daubster: Thank you! Well my girlfriend was here so i didn?t have more time but im very happy with my 3rd place
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-27 07:12:22 UTC
Post #154735
This thread has been closed by a Moderator?
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-27 07:12:59 UTC
Post #154736
Since you asked so nicely.
You must be logged in to post a response.