JC, do you actually think that if a mass audience calls a map "fun" that it will influence others to think the same? Playing the map with others determines fun. You cant force someone to believe what they are doing is fun, thats stupid. I personally love custom detailed maps that took time and effort. (The only good one ive came upon online was de_rats) I remember once in HL1 I downloaded a really cool looking nicely made movie theatre map. It was well done, and had cool features and custom textures, but it played like crap! No one would join it, and the ones who did explored, played 2 rounds, then quit. Iceworld is fun, but it took about 5 minutes to make.
The point of this thread was to have a competition to take these fun, but shitty looking maps and use our skills to better them. Maybe the winner version would catch on online? I think this is a good idea for a contest. :) Just decompile the chosen map, get the proportion, delete all of it, and start mapping! This could be done in Source, and HL1! Since the maps are simple, more time could go into it. COME ON GUYS, LETS DO THIS!!!!! :)
Anonymous member: "I agree, lets do it!"
2nd Anonymous member: "I second that! DO IT!"
3rd Anonymous member: "Give me one of those things, you know, oh ya, give me one cheeseburger!" (That means do this competition)