No offence, Unbreakable and Rowleybob but SlayerA and Seventh already said that they were going to try to give it asap.Why further talk?
"Hehe, I've got the results but not going to post em after 3 weeks".There is no such thing like that.They give it asap.
Um, we were done until you opened your mouth
And nobody said they were "hording" the results... besides I dun care what your excuse is, 3 weeks is an epic amount of time to judge a compo, and is totally unacceptable, period.
Exactly, it's not like we're holding onto the results and saying "Hehe, let's piss off TWHL today and NOT POST THE RESULTS!!!"
Um, I never said nor implied that, and you know it. I merely said if the difficult part of getting the results out is coding them, then fuck all to the coding, simply post the results in the compo thread when they're ready.
I was done talking about this, but it seems you all are interested in bringing it up again, so let's have a fun exercise examining a typical judging process the way I see it:
Suppose you have 15 entries, which to quote Luke again is an
epic amount of entries for a typical compo. (really, I'd be quite interested to see the actual average of entries per)
I've not judged a sanctioned compo, but I've reviewed more than a couple maps to make an educated guess about the process. As for those entries recieved:
4-7 - Will be severely unfinished or just poory concieved/implemented. For these maps you wouldn't need more than a minute or too to write some notes and more importantly disqualify them from the running.
1-3 - Will be missing wads or will be otherwise unplayable. These take no time at all because they're immediately disqualified.
7-10 - Will be decent, thoughtful entries, though many of them mediocre or lacking in a crucial way. 1-2 of these entries will probably very nice and stand out from the rest.
All of this could easily be done in the span of an hour or a little more. At the mose approaching perhaps 2 hours if you recieved an above-average amount of really good entries.
Not helped by all the hassle of getting the entries, which are often corrupt, in stupid formats, archived badly, and all around the Web since we can only upload 2MB files here via PHP.
If the files don't meet the minimum standards to run, they should be disqualified, period.
The longest/hardest part of the process--besides coding maybe--would be agreeing with the other judge... still, I don't see how this could take more than a few days, perhaps a week at most.
I really could give a fuck about all this until Ant took my comments as a personal attack, and started whining in his grandfatherly tone... All I was really trying to do was give my impression.
/holy jesus long rant