The Whole Half-Life
Level design resources for GoldSource, Source, and beyond
Featured map: dm_undergroundlab by The Mad Carrot

The Map Vault Review-a-thon Created 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:17:42 UTC by Daubster Daubster

  1. Forums
  2. Site Comments and Suggestions
  3. View Thread

Created 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:17:42 UTC by Daubster Daubster

Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:17:42 UTC Post #153005
Want a Mapvault award shining in your profile?
If you do - read on.

The mapvault review-a-thon is a competition, where the prize is a MV award.
It's pretty simple, if you wanna win it. You just have to review/comment as much maps as possible till' christmas. Your reviews will be judged by the moderators. Quality goes over quantity here.
You can only review/comment the maps that have been posted after November 1st. Constructive criticism is the main requirement.
If you want to participate - just let us know in this thread. Your comments will be judged in a 5* system and by Christmas - your scores will be calculated and the member with the highest score will be the winner.

May the competition begin!
Good luck. :)
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
Elon Yariv
Elon Yariv
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:34:40 UTC Post #153010
Hmm... no Hl1 maps=not fair :roll:

Edit:

*downloads and commets on crete2
Elon Yariv Elon Yariv
Ansith
Ansith
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:38:08 UTC Post #153011
I could sure go for one of those shiney awards but :cry: I'm not very good at getting awards
Ansith Ansith
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:38:57 UTC Post #153012
@Elon: ? What do ya mean? You can review any map posted after november 1st 2005.
The vault doesn't matter either.. :)
@Ansith: You got nothing to lose.. :)
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
Elon Yariv
Elon Yariv
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:40:08 UTC Post #153013
Ok but you will never see it. :P
Elon Yariv Elon Yariv
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:41:28 UTC Post #153014
I wouldn't worry about that.. ;)
Are ya in or not?
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
Ansith
Ansith
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:52:49 UTC Post #153016
I'm in, ive wanted an award since a few weeks back when I thought i needed to contribute something to the site for all the help ive gotten.
Ansith Ansith
Habboi
Habboi
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:54:32 UTC Post #153017
Heck this is also good for people submitting maps, means people will actually download then rather than commenting on the picture.
Habboi HabboiSticky White Love Glue
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:55:28 UTC Post #153018
:glad:
My point exactly
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
Madcow
Madcow
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:58:13 UTC Post #153019
Nice idea Daubster! :)

I put a bet on Elon!
Madcow MadcowSpy zappin my udder
Ansith
Ansith
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 11:59:57 UTC Post #153020
Me too he is good at reviewing, after all he reviewed my first 2 maps :)
Ansith Ansith
Archie
Archie
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:09:09 UTC Post #153021
i'm in!
Archie ArchieGoodbye Moonmen
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:12:56 UTC Post #153023
Finally.. Someone besides Elon has the guts to enter.. :glad:
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
Ansith
Ansith
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:19:18 UTC Post #153024
Um yeah i said i was as well...
Ansith Ansith
Archie
Archie
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:20:09 UTC Post #153025
do comments already made on maps posted after nov 1st count?
Archie ArchieGoodbye Moonmen
Elon Yariv
Elon Yariv
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:20:46 UTC Post #153026
Check Dm_crete2 :P
Elon Yariv Elon Yariv
Ansith
Ansith
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:21:35 UTC Post #153027
are you just going to look at all the maps posted after nov 1st?
Ansith Ansith
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:32:58 UTC Post #153029
@Hunter: Yes, they do.
@Ansith: I will.
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
Archie
Archie
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 12:46:58 UTC Post #153035
check out

crete2... again

&

The Arena - Room 1

&

Justice - CS:S
Archie ArchieGoodbye Moonmen
BrattyLord
BrattyLord
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-18 19:57:33 UTC Post #153089
Great Idea!

Getting people interesting in other people's maps!!
BrattyLord BrattyLord
rowleybob
rowleybob
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:01:36 UTC Post #153173
...people will actually download then rather than commenting on the picture.
User posted image
O RLY? :P

If this little compo gets users to give better than one-sentence, or one-phrase, or even one-word reviews that are not punctuated, I will rejoice, and sacrifice a calf for Lucifer!

However, I think most are either too busy, too self-indulged, or waste too much time in the "Stuff" forum--that'd be me--to worry about what their peers are doing. It's really their loss, because you learn a lot by playing other's maps.

Godspeed Map Vault Review-a-thon! <rowleybob goes back to his old pastime of reviewing maps from 2003 lol. :glad:
rowleybob rowleybob
Dorian27
Dorian27
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:07:35 UTC Post #153175
Here is a little help for those who want a CS map to rate. I wont be able to enter this Competition, sadly I barely have enough time to work on my own maps, let alone review someone elses.
Dorian27 Dorian27
rowleybob
rowleybob
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:13:16 UTC Post #153176
It really doesn't take that long, and It's a nice mini break from whatever else your woring on to play/rate somebody's masterpiece.

I Think I'm going to take my own advice right now and write some bowel-destructing reviews... :P
rowleybob rowleybob
Dorian27
Dorian27
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:17:08 UTC Post #153178
I dont mean to spam this thread, but I'm at work right now, so I can't "take a mini break from whatever else I'm doing" when I'm not a work, I'm with my girlfriend, or mapping, or doing homework, or at school. I cherish my free time, and I get things done that I need to do. rating other people's maps just doesnt fit in sometimes. I'm sorry, if that offends anyone.
Dorian27 Dorian27
rowleybob
rowleybob
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:21:09 UTC Post #153179
I dont mean to spam this thread
Too late :(

You shouldn't take it personally at all. Almost nobody rates maps. It's not a big deal, really.

The real loss is to the person not doing the rating, anyway, because you can learn so much from other's stuff--even the really bad maps have cool things in them often! ;)
rowleybob rowleybob
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:29:07 UTC Post #153180
Way to go, rowley.. :)
I suppose you're in this compo?
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
rowleybob
rowleybob
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:31:24 UTC Post #153181
Oui Oui!
rowleybob rowleybob
Archie
Archie
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:42:11 UTC Post #153182
you gotta rate my aim_dust_night review, daubster!

Edit -

are you gonna rate them all, like just before you leave at night?
Archie ArchieGoodbye Moonmen
Spooky
Spooky
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 13:43:13 UTC Post #153183
I'll participate. Mmmm... nice shiny award.
Spooky Spooky
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 14:58:38 UTC Post #153205
@Hunter: Rated and yes, I check for reviews before I leave and write the ratings down.. :)
@Spooky: :glad:

Edit: Just finished reviewing the comments.. Don't spam the thread telling me bout yer comments. I'll manage to notice them myself :)
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
Seventh-Monkey
Seventh-Monkey
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 15:51:24 UTC Post #153214
Pwnage moderation by m' main maaaaan Anthony. Big it up.
Seventh-Monkey Seventh-MonkeyPretty nifty
rowleybob
rowleybob
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 16:08:47 UTC Post #153216
He said "Big it up," lololo... :)
rowleybob rowleybob
Archie
Archie
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 16:27:33 UTC Post #153221
Hmm... no Hl1 maps=not fair
Yep, i've been extra nice to you elon
Archie ArchieGoodbye Moonmen
shadowhunter
shadowhunter
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 18:05:29 UTC Post #153269
so anywhere in the vault?
shadowhunter shadowhunter
BrattyLord
BrattyLord
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 18:06:16 UTC Post #153270
Are you ever going to do this again?
BrattyLord BrattyLord
shadowhunter
shadowhunter
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 18:17:45 UTC Post #153276
ill join why not?
shadowhunter shadowhunter
Seventh-Monkey
Seventh-Monkey
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 18:35:00 UTC Post #153284
Bratty: probably, if it does well :).
Seventh-Monkey Seventh-MonkeyPretty nifty
shadowhunter
shadowhunter
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 19:04:15 UTC Post #153296
if you want a head start i posted an unfinished map called Emphasis
shadowhunter shadowhunter
Elon Yariv
Elon Yariv
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 19:09:59 UTC Post #153298
Didn't daubster just ask not to spam this thread with comment/map pimps? :P No use, people will find it anyway.
Elon Yariv Elon Yariv
shadowhunter
shadowhunter
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 19:21:53 UTC Post #153304
sorry :aghast:
shadowhunter shadowhunter
Tosse
Tosse
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 20:18:08 UTC Post #153309
Im in :)
Tosse Tosse
slighty_insane
slighty_insane
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-19 20:25:38 UTC Post #153313
were does it say no hl1 maps and how do i join
slighty_insane slighty_insane
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 02:46:02 UTC Post #153345
@Slightly_insane: Readn teh introdiction again.
Keep this up, people - the mapvault has never been so active before.. :D

And another thing.. You can advertise your new maps here, that's great. I just asked not to spam the thread by telling me, what maps you reviewed.
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
FresheD
FresheD
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 12:48:19 UTC Post #153424
So you need to review maps that are HALF-LIFE 1 and CAN BE RATED??? :o
FresheD FresheD
Daubster
Daubster
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 12:53:55 UTC Post #153427
No.. You need to review EVERY map in EVERY vault, for ANY MOD no matter if it CAN BE RATED or not!
Why must I repeat myself?? :zonked:
Daubster DaubsterVault Dweller
FresheD
FresheD
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 12:57:11 UTC Post #153428
But that's a advantage for poeple with hl2? :D

Anyway, I was to lazy to read the whole page, that's why daubster, forgive me this one time! :P
FresheD FresheD
shadowhunter
shadowhunter
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 12:59:33 UTC Post #153429
he's right i two dont have hl2
shadowhunter shadowhunter
Dorian27
Dorian27
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 13:07:15 UTC Post #153430
The source cometitions also pose a big advantage for those with HL2 as well, whats your point?
Dorian27 Dorian27
Seventh-Monkey
Seventh-Monkey
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 13:08:20 UTC Post #153432
Tough.
Seventh-Monkey Seventh-MonkeyPretty nifty
shadowhunter
shadowhunter
Posted 18 years ago2005-12-20 13:15:06 UTC Post #153434
how can we reciew EVERYTHING without it? i only have 63mb of ram do the math. and no i cant afford a new computer
shadowhunter shadowhunter
You must be logged in to post a response.